|Brief communication||Peer reviewed|
Cite as: Ramirez A, Rowe EW, Arruda PH, et al. Use of equine-origin antitoxins in piglets prior to exposure to mitigate the effects of Clostridium difficile infection – a pilot study. J Swine Health Prod. 2014;22(1):29–32.
Also available as a PDF.
Administration to newborn pigs of an oral or intraperitoneal dose of equine-origin Clostridium difficile antitoxin 4 hours before orogastric inoculation with a swine-origin C difficile field isolate resulted in lower histopathology scores 72 hours post challenge than in pigs receiving no antitoxin (P < .05).
La administración a cerdos recién nacidos de una dosis intraperitoneal u oral de la antitoxina Clostridium difficile de origen equino 4 horas antes de la inoculación orogástrica con un aislado de campo de C difficile de origen porcino resultó en índices histopatológicos más bajos 72 horas después del reto que en cerdos que no recibieron la antitoxina (P < .05).
L’administration orale ou intra-péritonéale à des porcelets nouveau-nés d’une dose d’antitoxine contre Clostridium difficile d’origine équine 4 heures avant l’inoculation oro-gastrique d’un isolat de C difficile d’origine porcine a résulté en une diminution des pointages des lésions histopathologiques 72 heures post-inoculation comparativement à des porcelets ne recevant aucune antitoxine (P < .05).
Keywords: swine, Clostridium difficile, Clostridium difficile-associated disease, antitoxin, prevention
Search the AASV web site for pages with similar keywords.
Received: April 11, 2013
Accepted: May 15, 2013
In the last 10 years, Clostridium difficile has been implicated as a major cause of neonatal diarrhea in pigs.1 Clostridium difficile infection (CDI) typically affects piglets ranging in age from 1 to 7 days. Clinical signs of CDI include diarrhea, abdominal distention, and scrotal edema, with most of the pathology being attributed to toxins A and B.2 The prevalence of C difficile is widespread in the United States and has been referred to as the most important uncontrolled cause of neonatal diarrhea in the pig.1 This is supported by many studies indicating a prevalence rate of about 50% and the fact that C difficile may affect litter productivity by as much as 10% to 15%.1,3,4
In human medicine, intravenous administration of immunoglobulins for treatment of CDI has variable results.5-8 This variability may be due to differences in timing of antibody administration and toxin exposure.7 In a mouse model, McPherson et al5 reported that intravenous administration of immunoglobulins is most effective when performed at the same time as toxin infusion. The use of prophylactic antibiotics has been unsatisfactory and unrewarding for swine producers.
The objective of this pilot study was to investigate if administration of an equine-origin antitoxin would serve as a beneficial intervention in minimizing the clinical and histologic effects in neonatal pigs infected with C difficile.
Materials and methods
The experimental protocol was approved by the Iowa State University (ISU) Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee.
Animals and housing
Thirty-six newborn piglets were obtained from a commercial farrowing unit. Parturition was monitored on-farm and all piglets were farrowed onto a sterile drape or manually removed to prevent contact with the environment, as described by Lizer et al.9 The piglets were immediately dried and placed in clean plastic totes under heat lamps. Colostrum was collected from farrowing sows and mixed to create a single pooled colostrum stock. All piglets were orogastrically intubated and fed 10 mL of pooled colostrum, followed by 15 mL of milk replacer (Esbilac liquid puppy formula; Pet-Ag, Hampshire, Illinois), tagged, and transported back to ISU within 4 hours of birth. Pigs were randomly assigned to six groups (Table 1) using a random number generator (Excel; Microsoft, Redmond, Washington). Inoculated pigs (Groups D, E, and F) were housed in one room while non-inoculated pigs (Groups A, B, and C) were in a separate room to prevent cross-contamination. All pigs were individually housed in raised plastic decks partitioned into individual pens (approximately 0.7 × 0.7 m) with solid dividing walls and individual feeding bowls as described by Lizer et al.9 Pigs were fed milk replacer three times daily for the duration of the experiment (72 hours).
Table 1: Experimental design for conventional newborn pigs receiving saline or an oral or intraperitoneal dose of equine-origin Clostridium difficile antitoxin and inoculated 4 hours later with sham inoculum (non-infected) or C difficile spores (infected)
* For purposes of statistical analysis, treatment groups were further categorized as NI (non-infected), IA (infected and received antibodies), or I (infected but received no antibodies).
† Treatments: either oral saline (control) or equine plasma from horses hyperimmunized against C difficile toxins A and B (Mg Biologics, Ames, Iowa) administered either orally or intraperitoneally (IP).
‡ Pigs were inoculated orogastrically either with sham inoculum (phosphate buffered saline; NI) or with 2 × 109 C difficile spores 4 hours after receiving treatment of either saline (I), or oral or IP antibodies (IA).
Pigs in groups B, C, D, and E (Table 1) received an oral or intraperitoneal (IP) dose of equine-origin Clostridium difficile antitoxin, and pigs in groups A and F received a saline placebo. Toxin-neutralizing antitoxin was administered at the same time as pooled colostrum. Serum samples from all pigs were tested for circulating toxin-neutralizing antibodies prior to administration of colostrum and antitoxin, and 24 hours post administration.
Inoculum preparation was performed as described by Lizer et al.9 Briefly, pure pellets of C difficile (ISU isolate 13912–1) with a concentration of 2 × 109 spores per mL were used as the inoculum. This isolate is a 2008 field isolate from a 2-day-old scouring pig from northern Missouri that was submitted to ISU Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory. Immediately prior to challenge, spores were heat shocked in a water bath at 80°C for 10 minutes. Brain heart infusion broth with 0.1% taurocholic acid and 5% fetal bovine serum was added to the heated spore suspension at a concentration of 25% volume per volume (v/v) and incubated 1 hour at 37°C. Sterile phosphate buffered saline was used in the place of spores for controls (sham inoculum). A 1.25-mL inoculum dose or phosphate buffered saline was administered via a sterile gastric tube and flushed with 20 mL milk replacer. Pigs were inoculated 4 hours post administration of colostrum and antitoxin or saline.
Equine plasma from horses hyperimmunized against C difficile toxins A and B was obtained from Mg Biologics (Ames, Iowa). The hyperimmune equine plasma that was administered to the pigs had titers of 1:800 and 1:1600 for toxins A and B, respectively. Titers were determined by cell neutralization assay as described below.
Toxin-neutralizing antibodies were assessed in cell culture using Chinese hamster ovary cells according to the protocol established by Post et al.10 Briefly, Chinese hamster ovary cells are exposed to dilutions of serum and known concentrations of toxins A and B. Toxin and serum are incubated for 1 hour at 37ºC prior to cell exposure. Twenty-four hours later, the cells are assessed for cytopathic effect. The last dilution where no cytopathic effect is observed is reported as the antitoxin titer. The pooled colostrum sample was also tested for antibodies to toxins A and B.
Necropsy and histopathology
All pigs were euthanized by an intravenous overdose of pentobarbital at 72 hours post inoculation. At necropsy, weight, body condition (0 = normal, 1 = thin, 2 = emaciated), stomach fill (0 = empty, 1 = half full, 2 = full), consistency of large intestinal contents (0 = firm, 1 = normal, 2 = pudding-like, 3 = watery) were assessed with their respective scales, while dehydration, fecal staining of the perineum (used as a proxy for diarrhea), visible colonic necrosis and fibrin, and mesocolonic edema were assessed using a scale from 0 to 3 (0 = none, 1 = mild, 2 = moderate, 3 = severe) in a blinded fashion as previously described.4,9
Formalin-fixed tissues collected for histopathology included ileum, jejunum, descending colon, cecum, and a cross section through the spiral colon containing four to five loops. Tissues were evaluated for goblet cells, quantity of neutrophils in the lamina propria, mucosal alterations (ulcers and erosions), and mesenteritis (Lizer et al).9
Bacterial culture and toxin detection
After necropsy, spiral colon contents were cultured directly onto C difficile selective agar (CDSA; Remel, Lenexa, Kansas) in addition to routine aerobic and anaerobic plates. Toxin swabs collected from the rectum prior to inoculation and 48 and 72 hours post inoculation were assayed with a commercially available C. difficile Tox A/B II ELISA kit (TechLab, Blacksburg, Virginia) and analyzed on a microplate reader to grade the toxin levels on a scale from 0 through 4+ per manufacturer recommendations.
In analyzing the data, we combined scores into three general categories: clinical signs, gross lesions, and microscopic lesions. The scoring system for each category was based on that published by Lizer et al.9 Clinical sign scores were calculated by summing scores for body condition, dehydration, and perineal staining. Gross lesions included the summed scores of necrotizing lesions, mesocolonic edema, toxigenic culture, and toxin. Microscopic lesion scores were the sum of all histopathology changes noted. For statistical analysis, pigs in groups A, B, and C were combined in Group NI (non-infected), pigs in groups D and E were combined in Group IA (infected and received antitoxin), and pigs in Group F were in Group I (infected only), as summarized in Table 1. Statistical differences (P < .05) in group outcomes were determined by ANOVA, Tukey’s honestly significant difference (HSD) test, and Fisher’s exact test using JMP Pro 10 (SAS; Cary, North Carolina) statistical software.
Antibodies for toxins A and B were not detected in the pooled colostrum sample or in the serum sample from any pig prior to administration of hyperimmune equine plasma. Twenty-four hours later, all pigs that had received antitoxin either by IP or oral administration (groups B, C, D, and E) had measurable levels of circulating antitoxin. All but one pig (Group B, titer 1:2) had toxin-neutralizing titers of 1:16 or greater. Pigs that had not received antitoxin had no detectable antibodies to C difficile toxins 24 hours post administration of colostrum.
Clostridium difficile was isolated from the colon of all inoculated pigs at necropsy. One pig from Group A and one from Group B were culture-positive for C difficile at the end of the study and were excluded from all analyses. Both were from non-infected groups. Additionally, C difficile toxin was detected in six of the 16 pigs (37.5%) in group IA and four of the eight pigs (50.0%) in group I.
At the time of colostrum administration, mean body weight was 1.38 kg (SD 0.263). At 72 hours post challenge, the mean weights of the infected pigs (Group D, E, and F; 1.26 kg, SD 0.264) and non-infected pigs (Group A, B, and C; 1.40 kg, SD 0.329) did not differ (P = .21). Additionally, at necropsy, mean weights of infected pigs not receiving antitoxin (Group F; 1.21 kg, SD 0.270) and of those that did receive antitoxin (groups D and E; 1.29 kg, SD 0.265) did not differ (P = .46).
Results of scoring at necropsy are summarized in Table 2. There were no statistical differences in means among the groups. Two pigs in the I group and two in the IA group had mesocolonic edema. In the I group, both pigs had moderate edema, and in the IA group, one had mild and the other moderate edema. Intestinal content consistency did not differ among pigs regardless of treatment group. Gross intestinal lesions were not observed.
Table 2: Summary data from mean (± SE) necropsy scores for body condition, dehydration, perineal staining, and stomach fill for conventional newborn pigs in a Clostridium difficile antitoxin study*
* Study design described in Table 1. All animals were euthanized 72 hours post inoculation. Scoring system: body condition, 0 = normal, 1 = thin, 2 = emaciated; dehydration and perineal staining, 0 = none, 1 = mild, 2 = moderate, 3 = severe; stomach fill, 0 = empty, 1 = half full, 2 = full as described by Yaeger et al.4
† Two of the original 12 NI pigs were culture-positive for C difficile and were excluded from analysis.
‡ Groups compared using analysis of variance with P < .05 considered statistically significant.
SE = standard error; NI = non-infected; IA = infected and treated with equine-origin antibodies to C difficile; I = infected only (no antibodies).
Microscopic lesions were summed to provide a total microscopic lesion score. Mean total scores for NI (2.90, SD 0.526) and IA pigs (3.69, SD 0.561) did not differ (P = .86). However, mean total score did differ between animals in Group I (7.88, SD 2.467) and either Group NI (P = .02) or Group IA (P = .04).
Lower total microscopic lesion scores in infected pigs receiving antitoxin either orally or IP suggest a beneficial effect of administration of antitoxin prior to exposure to C difficile. Other parameters measured differed numerically in groups treated with antitoxin, but due to small sample sizes and wide variances in the groups they were not statistically significant. Although perineal staining did not differ among groups, it is interesting to note that all pigs from Group I had some degree of staining at necropsy, while five pigs in Group NI and five in Group IA had no staining.
Results of this pilot study also support findings by McPherson et al5 in that intravenous administration of immunoglobulins can be effective in protecting mice when administered at the time of exposure. This intervention can easily be performed under routine swine production practices, as CDI is often predictable within a particular swine operation. Although our study size was small, there appeared to be no clinical or statistical difference in the parameters measured between pigs treated with immunoglobulins IP or orally. In routine field settings, oral administration would be simpler and less invasive for the pigs, assuming they are treated before gut closure has occurred.
In this study, we used harvested plasma containing immunoglobulins that had been specifically targeted against C difficile A and B toxins. Human studies5-8 utilize immunoglobulins obtained from pooled human blood and containing antibodies to many different antigens. The ability to obtain plasma with high levels of C difficile A and B antitoxins maximizes the potential for effectiveness. The plasma used in this study is now available commercially (AbSolution Pg, Mg Biologics) at an approximate cost of US $0.50 per pig.
Our study was not designed to evaluate the effect of inoculation dose on CDI lesions. Prior work11has demonstrated that the dose of inoculum does appear to affect the severity of clinical and histopathologic lesions associated with CDI. The inoculum dose used in the present study was very high. The effectiveness of the antitoxin antibodies may even be greater under natural settings, although we did not study this.
• Lower total microscopic lesion scores in treated piglets in this study suggest beneficial effects from administration of antitoxin prior to exposure to C difficile in piglets.
• Under the conditions of this study, in piglets treated before gut closure occurs, oral administration of C difficile antitoxin may be more practical than IP administration under routine field settings.
This project was funded in part by Mg Biologics. The authors would like to thank Cathy Martens for laboratory assay work and the ISU Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory Bacteriology section for help with aerobic and anaerobic cultures.
Conflict of interest
1. Songer JG, Anderson MA. Clostridium difficile: an important pathogen of food animals. Anaerobe. 2006;12:1–4.
2. Songer J, Post K, Larson D, Jost B, Glock R. Infection of neonatal swine with Clostridium difficile. J Swine Health Prod. 2000;8:185–189.
3. Songer JG. The emergence of Clostridium difficile as a pathogen of food animals. Anim Health Res Rev. 2004;5:321–326.
4. Yaeger MJ, Kinyon JM, Songer JG. A prospective, case control study evaluating the association between Clostridium difficile toxins in the colon of neonatal swine and gross and microscopic lesions. J Vet Diagn Invest. 2007;19:52–59.
5. McPherson S, Rees CJ, Ellis R, Soo S, Panter SJ. Intravenous immunoglobulin for the treatment of severe, refractory, and recurrent Clostridium difficile diarrhea. Dis Colon Rectum. 2006;49:640–645.
6. Juang P, Skledar SJ, Zgheib NK, Paterson DL, Vergis EN, Shannon WD, Ansani NT, Branch RA. Clinical outcomes of intravenous immune globulin in severe Clostridium difficile-associated diarrhea. Am J Infect Control. 2007;35:131–137.
7. Bobo LD, Dubberke ER, Kollef M. Clostridium difficile in the ICU: the struggle continues. Chest. 2011;140:1643–1653.
8. Saito T, Kimura S, Tateda K, Mori N, Hosono N, Hayakawa K, Akasaka Y, Ishii T, Sumiyama Y, Kusachi S, Nagao J, Yamaguchi K. Evidence of intravenous immunoglobulin as a critical supportive therapy against Clostridium difficile toxin-mediated lethality in mice. J Antimicrob Chemother. 2011;66:1096–1099.
9. Lizer JT, Madson DM, Schwartz KJ, Harris H, Bosworth BT, Kinyon JM, Ramirez A. Experimental infection of conventional neonatal pigs with Clostridium difficile: A new model. J Swine Health Prod. 2013;21:22–29.
10. Post KW, Jost BH, Songer JG. Evaluation of a test for Clostridium difficile toxins A and B for the diagnosis of neonatal swine enteritis. J Vet Diagn Invest. 2002;14:258–259.
11. Arruda PHE, Madson DM, Ramirez A, Rowe E, Lizer J, Songer JG. Effect of age, dose and antibiotic therapy on the development of Clostridium difficile infection in neonatal piglets. Anaerobe. 2013;22:104–110.