| |
Original research
|
Peer reviewed
|
Feed composition in herds
with or without postweaning Escherichia coli diarrhea in early-weaned
piglets
La composición
del alimento en piaras con o sin diarrea causada por Escherichia coli después
del destete en lechones de destete precoz
Composition des
aliments dans les troupeaux avec ou sans diarrhée colibacillaire postsevrage
chez les porcelets sevrés précocement
François
Cardinal, DVM, MSc; Sylvie D'Allaire, DVM, MSc, PhD; John M. Fairbrother,
BVSc, PhD
FC, SD, JMF: Faculté de
médecine vétérinaire, Université de Montréal,
St-Hyacinthe, Québec, Canada; Corresponding author: Dr François
Cardinal, Les Consultants Avi-Porc, 1320, boul Jean de Brébeuf, Drummondville,
Québec, Canada J2B 4T6; Tel: 819-478-0450; Fax: 819-478-1807; E-mail:
francoiscardinal@sympatico.ca.
Cite as: Cardinal
F, D'Allaire S, Fairbrother JM. Feed composition in herds with or without
postweaning Escherichia coli diarrhea in early-weaned piglets. J
Swine Health Prod. 2006;14(1):10-17.
Also
available as a PDF.
Summary
Objective: To conduct a preliminary screening of possible risk factors
associated with water and feed composition for postweaning Escherichia coli diarrhea
(PWECD) in early-weaned piglets.
Methods: A case-control study was conducted in Québec, Canada,
including 34 herds with weaning age less than 22 days: 17 herds in which PWECD
did not occur (Control; Group C) and 17 affected herds (Diarrhea; Group D).
Diagnoses of PWECD with colibacillary shock were confirmed by a provincial
diagnostic laboratory. Information on rations used in the nursery was collected
during a farm visit. Each ration was analyzed, and electrolytic balance was
calculated. Rations fed the day before the first occurrence of diarrhea in
Group D herds were compared to median values for rations fed on the same postweaning
days in Group C herds. Drinking water samples were also analyzed.
Results: Higher levels of soybean and canola products (sources of vegetal
proteins) were used in Group D herds the day before the first occurrence of
diarrhea. Calcium and magnesium levels were higher and zinc concentrations
and electrolytic balance were lower in the feeds of Group D herds than in the
feeds of Group C herds. There was no relationship between water composition
and PWECD status.
Implications: Feed content may play a role in the occurrence of PWECD.
Protein of animal origin should be included in the feed for the first 3 weeks
post weaning, and high calcium levels should be avoided for 1 week. Zinc oxide
supplementation is beneficial in reducing incidence of PWECD.
| Resumen
Objetivo: Realizar una revisión preliminar de los posibles factores
de riesgo asociados con la composición del alimento y del agua en la
diarrea causada por Escherichia coli después del destete (PWECD
por sus siglas en inglés) en lechones de destete precoz.
Métodos: Se realizó un estudio de casos y control en
Québec, Canadá, incluyendo 34 piaras con una edad de destete
menor a 22 días: 17 piaras en las que no se presentó
la PWECD (Grupo C) y 17 piaras afectadas (Grupo D). Un laboratorio de diagnóstico
provincial confirmó el diagnósticos de la PWECD con choque colibacilar.
Durante una visita a la granja se recopiló información sobre
las raciones utilizadas en el destete. Se analizó cada ración
y se calculó el balance electrolítico. Se compararon las raciones
ofrecidas el día anterior a la primera aparición de diarrea en
las piaras del Grupo D, con los valores de la mediana de las raciones ofrecidas
durante los mismos días post destete en las piaras del Grupo C. También
se analizaron muestras del agua potable.
Resultados: El día anterior a la primera aparición de
diarrea se utilizaron niveles más altos de productos de soya y canola
(fuentes de proteína vegetal) en las piaras del Grupo D. Los niveles
de calcio y magnesio fueron más altos y las concentraciones de zinc
y el balance electrolítico fueron más bajos en el alimento de
las piaras del Grupo D que en el alimento de las piaras del Grupo C. No hubo
relación entre la composición del agua y el estado de la PWECD.
Implicaciones: El contenido del alimento puede influir en la aparición
del PWECD. La proteína de origen animal debe incluirse en el alimento
en las 3 semanas posteriores al destete, y se deben evitar los niveles altos
de calcio por 1 semana. Suplementar con óxido de zinc ayuda a reducir
la incidencia del PWECD.
| Resumé
Objectif: Faire une évaluation préliminaire des facteurs
de risque potentiels associés
à la composition de l'aliment et de l'eau pour la diarrhée colibacillaire
postsevrage (PWECD selon le sigle anglais) chez les porcelets sevrés précocement.
Méthodes: Une étude de type cas-témoin a été effectuée
au Québec, Canada, dans des troupeaux dont l'âge au sevrage des
porcelets était de moins de 22 jours. Elle portait sur 34 troupeaux:
17 sans problème de PWECD (Groupe C) et 17 au prise avec cette condition
(Groupe D). Les diagnostics de PWECD avec choc colibacillaire ont été confirmés
par un laboratoire de diagnostic provincial. L'information sur les rations
utilisées dans la pouponnière a
été recueillie durant une visite de la ferme. Chaque ration a été analysée,
et la balance électrolytique a été calculée. Les
rations distribuées le jour avant la première apparition de diarrhée
dans les troupeaux du Groupe D ont été comparées aux valeurs
médianes des rations données pour les mêmes jours après
le sevrage dans les troupeaux du Groupe C. Des échantillons d'eau de
boisson ont aussi été analysés.
Résultats: Des niveaux plus élevés de produits
de soja et de colza (sources de protéines d'origine végétale)
ont été utilisés dans les troupeaux du Groupe D le jour
avant la première apparition de diarrhée. Les niveaux de magnésium
et de calcium étaient plus élevés et les concentrations
de zinc et la balance électrolytique étaient plus faibles dans
les aliments des troupeaux du Groupe D que dans ceux des troupeaux du Groupe
C. Il n'y avait pas d'association entre la composition de l'eau et le statut
de la PWECD.
Implications: La composition de l'aliment peut jouer un rôle
dans l'apparition de la PWECD. Des protéines d'origine animale devraient être
incluses dans l'alimentation pour les 3 premières semaines après
le sevrage, et des niveaux élevés de calcium devraient être évités
pour la première semaine. L'ajout d'oxyde de zinc est bénéfique
pour diminuer l'incidence de la PWECD.
|
Keywords: swine, postweaning
diarrhea, Escherichia coli, colibacillary shock, nursery feed
Search the AASV web site
for pages with similar keywords.
Received: May
5, 2004
Accepted: January
18, 2005
Postweaning Escherichia
coli diarrhea (PWECD) has been a problem in swine herds for many
years.1,2 After weaning, piglets must adapt to new nutrients present
in solid feed, and this is especially stressful when early weaning is practiced.
Reduced feed intake, intestinal villous atrophy,
crypt hyperplasia, and reduced enzymatic and absorption capacity are observed during
the postweaning period3-9 and may result
in transitory maldigestion and malabsorption of
nutrients.10-12 Presence of undigested nutrients in the gut lumen favors
proliferation of enterotoxigenic E coli
(ETEC) strains, attachment of these organisms
to the intestinal mucosa, and secretion of
enterotoxins.13 Diarrhea due to
hypersecretion of fluids and electrolytes and fecal
excretion of pathogenic E coli soon
follow.14-19 However, PWECD may be hyperacute, with pigs dying suddenly,
often without signs of diarrhea, and is then referred to as "colibacillary
shock."20,21
When piglets weaned at 4 days of age were experimentally challenged at 28 days of
age with ETEC strains administered by the oral or intragastric routes, diarrhea
occurred within 12 hours.22 Pigs challenged
by spreading broth cultures of ETEC strains on the pen floor developed diarrhea 1 to
5 days after weaning.23 Piglets may
become infected with ETEC on or soon after arrival in the nursery. Alternatively, some
piglets might already be infected before weaning, but may not excrete ETEC until
after weaning, when favorable conditions exist. In many herds, phase feeding is
practiced in the postweaning period in order to
provide a ration adapted to the developing piglets and to reduce feeding costs. It is
possible that in herds in which diarrhea occurs at
a later time after weaning, feeds that inhibit E
coli proliferation and attachment in the intestine, or that do not favor
maldigestion of nutrients, are fed for a longer
period. These arguments suggest that feed constituents should be examined in relation
to timing of diarrhea and not only globally over the postweaning period. Reported
incubation periods in challenge studies suggest that the feed used the day before
the appearance of diarrhea might be the factor that triggers proliferation of
E coli, and that it would be appropriate to look
specifically at this ration when investigating the
effect of feed on diarrhea.
Few epidemiological studies have evaluated risk factors associated with occurrence
of PWECD in early-weaned pigs. Before this study was initiated, reports from
diagnostic laboratories indicated that prevalence
of PWECD had increased during the previous 3 years in Québec, Canada (Dr
Michel Major, coordinator, Réseau d'Alerte
et d'Information Zoosanitaire, Ministère de l'Agriculture, des Pêcheries et
de l'Alimentation du Québec, 1999, personal communication). This increased
prevalence might have been related to recent
changes in management, such as early weaning. Since diet seems to play a key role in
the pathophysiology of PWECD, our objective was to conduct a preliminary screening
of possible risk factors associated with water and feed composition for PWECD
in early-weaned piglets. This project was part of a larger study designed to assess the
relative importance of management, feeding practices, and microbiological findings
in PWECD.
Materials and methods
Study sample
A total of 34 herds located in the province of Québec were involved in the study:
17 herds in which PWECD did not occur (Control; Group C) and 17 affected
herds (Diarrhea; Group D). The selection criteria for the Group C herds were nursery
mortality of < 2% and diarrhea affecting <
5% of piglets in the first 3 weeks postweaning in all batches of piglets during the
previous 6 months. Criteria for Group D herds were nursery mortality
>= 3% in at least one of four batches of piglets in the previous
3 months, diarrhea affecting >= 15% of piglets during the first 3 weeks
postweaning, PWECD confirmed by a provincial diagnostic laboratory, and colibacillary
shock occurring as part of the usual clinical presentation or necropsy findings.
Average weaning age was < 22 days in all herds.
An attempt was made to obtain an equal number of single-source and
multiple-source nurseries in both study groups. Herds
were referred by practicing veterinarians who had been invited by mail and telephone
to submit case and control herds according to the above definitions. After a
practicing veterinarian had referred a herd and
interviewed the producer, a farm visit with investigators was scheduled to ascertain
that selection criteria had been met. Farms were visited between November 1999 and
May 2001. One batch of piglets with diarrhea (Group D herds) or one batch of
piglets weaned for less than 3 weeks (Group C herds) was selected on each farm.
A batch was defined as a group of piglets weaned during the same week and housed in
the same room. Each batch was monitored for 23 days after weaning. In all herds,
housing was adequate and pigs were humanely cared for.
Data collection
Prevalence of diarrhea on the day of the farm visit, average weaning age,
weaning date, and date of first occurrence of diarrhea for the selected batch of piglets
were recorded, and the interval between weaning and occurrence of diarrhea was
calculated. Mortality during the nursery phase was also obtained for this batch of pigs.
Information on nursery rations used and date of feeding of each of these rations was
collected from a questionnaire administered by a single interviewer to each producer
during the farm visit (questionnaire available
upon request). Additional information was obtained from the manufacturer of the
feed used on the farm. For each ration, questions focused on amounts of cereal, soybean
and canola products, dairy products, blood
products, plasma products, plasma-substitute products, fish meal, meat meal,
and ground limestone (calcium carbonate, 35%
calcium) present in the feed. Ingredients included in each category are shown
in Table 1. Each ration used in the nursery phase was
sampled during the visit and analyzed on a dry
matter basis for crude protein, calcium, copper,
iron, potassium, magnesium, manganese, sodium, phosphorus,
zinc, chlorine, and sulfur (Shur-Gain
Laboratories, St Hyacinthe, Québec, Canada).
Electrolytic balance (EB) was calculated on a dry
matter basis for each ration used, according to
the following equation:24 EB (mmol per kg)
= [(Na+ 22.99) + (K+ 39.10) -
(Cl- 35.45)] x 1000, where
Na+, K+, and Cl-
are expressed as g per kg of feed.
Table 1: Description of categories of ingredients
used in rations for nursery pigs in a study to determine the effects
of dietary components on occurrence of postweaning Escherichia coli diarrhea

|
Using this information, a data set was constructed in which feed variables were
known for each day after weaning for each herd, with day of weaning identified as Day
0 (Figure 1).
Figure 1: Schema representing a method
developed to compare rations fed to piglets in herds in which postweaning
diarrhea either occurred (Group D, 17 herds) or did not occur (Group
C, 17 herds). Phase feeding and variation in the timing of rst occurrence
of diarrhea in Group D herds was taken into account. In the rst step,
the ration fed the day before occurrence of diarrhea in each Group D
herd was matched with the ration fed in Group C herds on the corresponding
postweaning day. For example, in Figure 1A, diarrhea first occurred in
Group D herd 17 on postweaning day 4 (blue cell), and the ration fed
the previous day (red cell) was selected for comparison to the median
of the Group C rations for that day (X3) (Figure 1A). Feed
composition variables considered were cereal, soybean and canola products,
dairy products, and ground limestone (calcium carbonate, 35% calcium),
crude protein, calcium, chlorine, copper, iron, magnesium, manganese,
phosphorus, potassium, sodium, sulfur, zinc, and electrolytic balance.
For each feed composition variable, the median value in the Group C rations
was compared to the value for each Group D herd. In a second step, the
difference (D) was calculated between the value for each variable in
the Group D rations and the median for the corresponding variables in
the Group C rations (Figure 1B). A Wilcoxon signed rank test was then
used to determine whether the distribution was centered on 0, which would
indicate no difference between the two groups for the variable considered.
A hypothetical graphical representation of these differences is presented
(Figure 1C). Herds are identied by number, and ration numbers correspond
to the phase of the nursery diet (eg, ration 1 is a phase 1 diet). Medians
of the Group C variables are identied by X with a subscript indicating
the postweaning day for which the median was calculated.

|
Water samples were collected during the farm visit. When a treatment system was
present, water was sampled along the line of
distribution after treatment. Samples were submitted to one of two private
laboratories accredited by the Ministère de
l'Agriculture, des Pêcheries et de l'Alimentation du
Québec (MAPAQ) (Agridirect or Laboratoire d'Environnement SM Inc,
Longueuil, Québec, Canada). For each sample,
magnesium, calcium, zinc, copper, iron, sodium, potassium, chloride,
manganese, boron, sulfate, nitrate, hardness,
alkalinity expressed as concentration of calcium
carbonate, and conductivity were measured. Water pH was measured directly on
the farm using a pocket-size pH tester with an accuracy of
+/- 0.1 (pHTestr 2, model 35624-20; Lesman Instrument
Company, Elmhurst, Illinois).
Statistical analyses
All statistical analyses were performed using SAS Software version 8.1 (SAS
Institute Inc, Cary, North Carolina). A Wilcoxon signed rank test was performed to
ensure that the groups were different in regard to prevalence of diarrhea and mortality. A
median two-sample test was used to compare results from water analysis for the
two groups of herds. To determine the effect of feed variables on occurrence of
diarrhea, rations fed to piglets on the day before
the first occurrence of diarrhea in Group D herds were compared to rations fed on
the same postweaning days in herds in Group C (Figure 1). These Group C rations
are referred to as "corresponding rations."
For each variable, we calculated the difference between the value for the ration used
on the day before first occurrence of diarrhea for each Group D herd and the value of
the median for the Group C corresponding ration. Hence, for each variable, a
distribution of the differences between Group D and C herds was obtained. A
Wilcoxon signed rank test was used to determine whether the distribution was centered
on 0,25 which would indicate no difference
in the variable between the two groups. This analysis was not performed when the
median of the variable was equal to 0 for Group C. Since values for feed variables cannot
be less than 0, a median of 0 for Group C does not mean that values are equally
distributed above and below 0, but only indicates that more than 50% of the
observations for this variable have a value of 0. When
a value of a variable for a Group D herd was compared to a median of 0, it was
only possible to obtain a difference >= 0. A
correlation test was performed on variables with significant differences to verify
that these variables were independent of each other. Variables were considered
independent when correlation coefficients were
< 0.50. For all statistical analyses,
differences were considered significant at
P < .05.
Results
The median prevalence of diarrhea on the day of the visit was 10.5% in Group D
and 0.0% in Group C (P < .001). Median
mortality was 4.5% in Group D and 0.9% in Group C
(P = .001). In Group D herds, diarrhea appeared between Days 3 and
23 (Figure 2), but usually before Day 10.
Figure 2: Batches of piglets were selected at
weaning in 17 herds in the province of Québec, Canada, using the
following criteria: litters weaned at <
22 days of age, nursery mortality 3% in at least one of four batches of
piglets in the previous 3 months, diarrhea affecting 15% of piglets during
the rst 3 weeks postweaning, postweaning Escherichia coli diarrhea
conrmed by a provincial diagnostic laboratory, and colibacillary shock
occurring as part of the usual clinical presentation or necropsy ndings
of postweaning diarrhea. Frequency represents the number of these herds
in which diarrhea rst occurred in the selected batch of piglets on each
day post weaning.

|
No difference was detected between the two groups for water pH and mineral
analysis (Table 2).
Table 2: Analysis of drinking water from 34
nurseries in Québec, Canada, in which postweaning Escherichia
coli diarrhea either occurred (Group D) or did not occur (Group C)

* Probability that the difference between Groups D and C
for the variable is signicantly different from zero; median two-sample
test.
†
Measured as calcium carbonate.
‡
Measured as nitrogen |
Complete feed, premix, and base mix used in the studied herds originated from
10 different feed companies: six for Group C and eight for Group D. Levels of
soybean and canola products, calcium, and magnesium were higher in the Group D feeds
on the day before the occurrence of diarrhea than in the corresponding rations
for Group C herds (Table 3). Zinc concentrations and EB were lower in the Group
D feeds than in the corresponding rations for Group C herds (Table 3). For all other
feed variables, there were no differences between groups. Correlation coefficients
between significant variables were all < 0.50.
Table 3: Feed composition for Group D herds
the day before occurrence of postweaning Escherichia coli diarrhea
in comparison with Group C herds for the corresponding ration*

* The study included herds in the province of Québec, Canada,
in which postweaning E coli diarrhea either occurred (17 herds;
group D) or did not (17 herds; Group C). Rations fed the day before the
rst occurrence of postweaning diarrhea in Group D herds were compared
to rations fed on the corresponding postweaning day in Group C herds.
†
Blood products, plasma products and substitutes, sh meal, and meat meal
were not tested because the median of Group C values was equal to zero.
‡
A negative value means that the median of Group D values is less than
the median of Group C values for the corresponding postweaning day
(eg, Group D herds used 14 kg/tonne less cereals than Group C for the
day before occurrence of diarrhea in Group D).
§ Probability that the difference between the Groups
D and C median values for the variable is signicantly different from
zero; Wilcoxon signed rank test. |
Discussion
Our observation that diarrhea did not occur before Day 3 suggests that
favorable conditions for E coli proliferation and
attachment in the intestine take some time to occur.
Although the number of herds selected for this study was small, comparison of
feed contents between groups clearly revealed that Group D herds were more likely to
use soybean and canola products in their rations than were Group C herds. This category
of ingredients is a vegetal source of proteins. No difference could be found for
categories of ingredients of animal origin because
some values were missing in each category. For the same reason, it was not possible to
group data in order to put all ingredients of
animal origin in the same category. Missing values were a problem because some feed
manufacturers would not reveal all information about the composition of their
rations. Since levels of crude protein in the
rations for both groups were similar, we can assume that more ingredients of animal
origin were used as a source of protein in Group C herds than in Group D herds.
It should be noted that in the category of soybean and canola products, the
predominant ingredients were soybean meal and soybean seed, with very little canola
meal being used. Soybean contains trypsin inhibitors and is known to be antigenic.
Various heat treatments have been used to
eliminate these factors from soybean with variable
success. When adverse effects due to soybean are observed, the inclusion proportion
is generally about or > 25% of the total
diet,13,26 which was the approximate
level of inclusion observed in our study (24.1% for Group D herds). Several
mechanisms have been proposed to explain the potential for soybean to cause or exacerbate
signs of postweaning diarrhea. A localized immune response may be induced by soybean
antigens, resulting in shortened intestinal villi
and increased crypt depth, and hence maldigestion and malabsorption, which might favor
E coli proliferation.26-28 Maldigestion
might also be the direct consequence of a lack of enzymes able to completely digest
soybean in weaned piglets.13 Also, insoluble
non-starch polysaccharides present in soybeans increase diet viscosity, which in turn
predisposes piglets to intestinal proliferation of
E coli.29
Group C herds seemed to use a more sophisticated ration for a longer period
after weaning and to adopt a phase-feeding program in which dietary components
were changed by smaller increments from one phase to another than in Group D
herds. Animal-source proteins are more costly than soybean and canola products,
which might explain why use of animal-source proteins was limited to shorter
periods. Several other authors have suggested that animal-source proteins provide
protection against PWECD. Tzipori et
al14 showed that when dairy products were added
to feed, occurrence of postweaning diarrhea was delayed and mortality was lower.
In Swedish herds without postweaning diarrhea, dairy products or fish meal were
included in the feed for piglets during the first
10 postweaning days to a greater extent than in herds in which postweaning
diarrhea occurred.30 Lower PWECD mortality
was reported when plasma products were included at 250 kg per tonne of
feed.31 In our study, none of the selected herds
used more than 88 kg per tonne of plasma products. However, we
could not analyze the relationship between the level of
plasma products and the occurrence of postweaning diarrhea because too many values
were missing. The protective role of feed ingredients of animal sources may be related
to easier digestion of these ingredients by the weaned piglet, reducing the amount of
undigested nutrients in the gut lumen and thus E
coli proliferation. Another explanation might be that animal-source
ingredients may stimulate higher feed intake by the piglet, helping to
prevent further postweaning diarrhea
problems.32
We observed a lower feed EB in Group D herds for the day before occurrence of
diarrhea than in the corresponding rations for Group C herds. A feed with low EB has
the potential to reduce blood pH, bicarbonate
level (HCO3-), and base
excess.24,33,34 Hypersecretory diarrhea due to
E coli also causes a decrease in blood pH,
pCO2, and base excess. The metabolic acidosis
that develops with diarrhea is due mainly to loss of
HCO3- via the feces. Death occurs
when the base excess becomes too low.15 In
hyperacute cases, death may also be caused by endotoxic
shock.20 Metabolic acidosis and reduced base excess are also present
before death caused by endotoxic
shock.35 Since low feed EB, hypersecretory diarrhea,
and endotoxic shock all result in decreased blood base excess in pigs, we suggest that
a low EB diet would potentiate the effects of PWECD on acute mortality. Even
though feed EB was in the normal
range24 for both Group C and D herds, the lower EB of
the feed for Group D herds might have caused a slight decrease in blood base excess
even before the onset of diarrhea. Hence, renal and respiratory compensation
mechanisms against metabolic acidosis would have
been overcome more rapidly.36 The influence
of feed EB on PWECD should be further evaluated.
As magnesium content differed only slightly in the feeds for the two groups, it would
be difficult to relate the difference to any particular ingredient. Moreover,
magnesium carbonate or magnesium oxide might have been added to the
feed,37 as the questionnaire did not ask for this information.
The level of calcium in the feed on the day prior to the occurrence of diarrhea
was higher in Group D herds. Higher levels of calcium, through supplementation
with limestone, increase feed buffering capacity, which may predispose to postweaning
diarrhea.38 Feeds with high buffering
capacity may increase stomach pH, which may favor maldigestion and proliferation of
E coli. It is interesting to note that among the
12 herds in which diarrhea appeared before Day 9, only one had a level of calcium
in the feed lower than the median for herds in Group C for the corresponding
rations (data not shown). This finding suggests that the level of calcium in the feed
may play a role in triggering diarrhea, and that this effect is more important during
the first week post weaning than at later times. This would make sense, since the
inability of the early-weaned piglet to secrete
sufficient HCl to maintain a low stomach pH is
transitory.3
It is well known that levels of zinc oxide between 2400 and 3000 g per tonne
of feed reduce the incidence of postweaning diarrhea and related
mortality.39 Such levels would yield 1720 to 2160 g per
tonne of zinc on a feed analysis.37 Although
the median zinc concentration in the feed used on the day prior to the occurrence of
diarrhea in group D (2182 g per tonne) was higher than 2160 g per tonne, six of the
17 Group D herds used no zinc oxide supplementation. Moreover, the feed
concentration of zinc in Group D herds on the day prior to the onset of diarrhea was
lower than that in the Group C corresponding rations. Hence, our results confirm
the beneficial effects of zinc oxide supplementation reported by
others.39
In our study, we found no relationship between water composition and
PWECD status, possibly due to the low variability
in water constituents among herds. Thus, we conclude that drinking water similar
in composition to that reported in Table 2 would not be considered an important
factor in the development of PWECD.
The association between diarrhea and some feed categories could not be evaluated
when the Group C median was equal to 0 for that variable, because this might have
resulted in bias for differences between Groups D and C to be > 0 by the
Wilcoxon signed rank test. These feed categories
included blood products, plasma products, plasma substitutes, fish meal, and
meat meal. As feed manufacturers were reluctant to reveal the level of inclusion in the
diet for these categories, there were several missing values for these variables.
Since a multivariate statistical analysis was not possible with the type of data in
our study, a correlation test was used on significant variables. No correlation was
found between significant variables, indicating that these variables were
independent from each other.
Finally, the power of this study was relatively low because sample size was
small. Since this was a preliminary study, the overall goal was to evaluate the
association of as many potential risk factors for
PWECD as possible. Hence, we focused on a larger number of variables in each herd
rather than on a greater sample size. It is also
important to note that herds without signs of diarrhea were compared to herds
experiencing severe PWECD problems. It is possible that pathogenic
E coli were not present in some Group C herds. In these
herds, PWECD would not occur whether or not risk factors for PWECD existed. This
might reduce the differences between Groups
C and D with respect to risk factors related to water and feed composition, and
would also decrease the power of our study. Therefore, variables not identified as
risk factors in our study might actually be associated with PWECD. Results of this
study should be used in an experimental design to validate the
findings.
Implications
- Feed content plays a role in the occurrence of PWECD.
- To prevent or reduce PWECD-related losses, protein of animal origin
should be included in the feed for the first 3 weeks post weaning.
- High calcium levels in nursery feed should be avoided, especially in
the first week post weaning.
- Zinc oxide supplementation is beneficial in reducing incidence of PWECD.
- Under the conditions of this study, there was no relationship
between water composition and PWECD status.
Acknowledgements
We gratefully thank participating farmers and veterinarians for their cooperation
in this project. We also thank the Conseil de recherches en pêche et en
agroalimentaire du Québec (CORPAQ), the Fédération
des Producteurs de Porcs du Québec (FPPQ), and the Fondation Desjardins for their
financial contribution.
References
1. Palmer NC, Hulland TJ. Factors predisposing
to the development of coliform gastroenteritis in weaned
pigs. Can Vet J. 1965;6:310-316.
2. Svendsen J, Larsen JL, Bille N. Outbreaks of
post weaning Escherichia coli diarrhea in pigs.
Nord Vet Med. 1974;26:314-322.
3. Cranwell PD, Titchen DA. Gastric secretion
in newly born pigs. Res Vet Sci. 1974;16:105-107.
4. Efird RC, Armstrong WD, Herman DL. The development of digestive capacity in young
pigs: effects of age and weaning system. J Anim
Sci. 1982;55:1380-1387.
5. Hampson DJ. Alterations in piglet small
intestinal structure at weaning. Res Vet
Sci. 1986;40:32-40.
6. Hampson DJ, Kidder DE. Influence of creep feeding and weaning on brush border enzyme
activities in the piglet small intestine. Res Vet
Sci. 1986;40:24-31.
7. Lindemann MD, Cornelius SG, El Kandelgy SM, Moser RL, Pettigrew JE. Effect of age,
weaning and diet on digestive enzyme levels in the piglet.
J Anim Sci. 1986;62:1298-1307.
8. Cera KR, Mahan DC, Cross RF, Reinhart GA, Whitmoyer RE. Effect of age, weaning
and postweaning diet on small intestinal growth
and jejunal morphology in young swine. J Anim
Sci. 1988;66:574-584.
9. Cera KR, Mahan DC, Reinhart GA. Effect of weaning, week postweaning and diet
composition on pancreatic and small intestinal luminal
lipase response in young swine. J Anim Sci.
1990;68:384-391.
10. van Beers-Schreurs HMG, Vellenga L, Wensing T, Breukink HJ. The pathogenesis of the
post-weaning syndrome in weaned piglets: a review.
Vet Q. 1992;14:29-34.
11. Nabuurs MJA, Hagendorn A, van Zijderveld FG. Effects of weaning and enterotoxigenic
Escherichia coli on net absorption in the small intestine
of pigs. Res Vet Sci. 1994;56:379-385.
12. Pluske JR, Hampson DJ, Williams IH. Factors influencing the structure and function of the
small intestine in the weaned pig: a review. Livest Prod
Sci. 1997;51:215-236.
13. Etheridge RD, Seerley RW, Huber TL. The effect of diet on fecal moisture, osmolarity of
fecal extracts, products of bacterial fermentation and
loss of minerals in feces of weaned pigs. J Anim
Sci. 1984;58:1403-1411.
14. Tzipori, D, Chandler D, Smith M, Makin T, Hennessy D. Factors contributing to
postweaning diarrhoea in a large intensive piggery.
Aust Vet J. 1980;56:274-278.
15. Andrén B, Persson S. Acid-base and
electrolyte changes in 1-3 days old piglets infected with
enteropathogenic Escherichia coli and in spontaneous
cases of piglet diarrhoea. Acta Vet Scand. 1983;24:84-98.
16. Miller BG, Newby TJ, Stokes CR, Bourne FJ. Influence of diet on postweaning malabsorption
and diarrhea in the pig. Res Vet Sci. 1984;36:187-193.
17. Hampson DJ, Fu ZF, Smith WC. Pre-weaning supplementary feed and porcine post-weaning
diarrhea. Res Vet Sci. 1988;44:309-314.
18. Kelly D, O'Brien JJ, McCracken KJ. Effect
of creep feeding on the incidence, duration and
severity of post-weaning diarrhea in pigs. Res Vet
Sci. 1990;49:223-228.
19. Mezoff AG, Jensen NJ, Cohen MB. Mechanisms of increased susceptibility of immature and
weaned pigs to Escherichia coli heat-stable
enterotoxin. Pediatr Res. 1991;29:424-428.
*20. Moxley RA, Erickson ED, Breisch S. Shock associated with enteric colibacillosis in suckling
and weaned swine. Proc George A. Young Swine Conf
& Ann Nebraska SPS Swine Conf. Lincoln,
Nebraska. 1988;33-38.
21. Faubert C, Drolet R. Hemorrhagic
gastroenteritis caused by Escherichia coli in piglets:
clinical, pathological and microbiological findings.
Can Vet J. 1992;33:251-256.
22. Madec F, Bridoux N, Bounaix S, Cariolet R, Duval-Iflah Y, Hampson DJ, Jestin A.
Experimental models of porcine post-weaning colibacillosis
and their relationship to post-weaning diarrhea and
digestive disorders as encountered in the field.
Vet Microbiol. 2000;72:295-310.
*23. Melin L, Mattsson S, Wallgren P. Challenge with pathogenic strains of
E coli at weaning. Clinical signs and reisolation of challenge strains.
Proc IPVS. Melbourne, Australia. 2000:22.
*24. Dourmad JY, Meschy F. Le bicarbonate de sodium en nutrition porcine.
Proc Conf GTV/ SPACE. France. 1998:1-12.
25. Fisher L, van Belle G, eds. Biostatistics. A
Methodology for the Health Sciences. New York, New
York: John Wiley & Sons; 1993.
26. Dréau D, Lallès JP, Philouze-Romé V, Toullec
R, Salmon H. Local and systemic immune responses
to soybean protein ingestion in early-weaned pigs.
J Anim Sci. 1994;72:2090-2098.
27. Dunsford BR, Knabe DA, Haensly WE. Effect of dietary soybean meal on the microscopic
anatomy of the small intestine in the early-weaned
pig. J Anim Sci. 1989;67:1855-1863.
28. Li DF, Nelssen JL, Reddy PG, Blecha F, Hancock JD, Allee G, Goodband RD, Klemm
RD. Transient hypersensitivity to soybean meal in
the early-weaned pig. J Anim Sci. 1990;68:1790-1799.
*29. McDonald DE, Pethick DW, Mullan BP, Hampson DJ. Increased intestinal viscosity
depresses carcass growth and encourages intestinal
proliferation of Escherichia coli in weaner pigs.
Proc IPVS. Melbourne, Australia. 2000:21.
*30. Löfstedt M, Holmgren N, Lundeheim N.
Risk factors for postweaning diarrhea in Swedish
pig herds. Proc IPVS. Melbourne, Australia. 2000:367.
31. Bosi P, Han IK, Jung HJ, Heo KN, Perini S, Castellazzi AM, Casini L, Creston D,
Gremokolini C. Effect of different spray dried plasmas on
growth, ileal digestibility, nutrient deposition, immunity
and health of early-weaned pigs challenged with
E coli K88. Asian-Aust J Anim Sci. 2001;14:1138-1143.
32. Madec F, Bridoux N, Bounaix S, Jestin A.
Measurement of digestive disorders in the piglet at
weaning and related risk factors. Prev Vet
Med. 1998;35:53-72.
*33. Mongin P. Recent advances in dietary anion-cation balance: applications in poultry.
Proc Nutr Soc. 1981;40:285-294.
34. Patience JF, Wolynetz MS. Influence of
dietary undetermined anion on acid-base status and
performance in pigs. J Nutr. 1990;12:579-587.
35. Li JX, Oliver JR, Lu CY, Grantham KD,
Philips JB. Age-related differences in responses to
endotoxin infusion in unanesthetized piglets. Circ
Shock. 1993;41:40-47.
36. Robinson NE. Homeostasis. In: Cunningham JG, ed.
Textbook of Veterinary Physiology. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania: WB Saunders
Company; 1992:601-610.
37. National Research Council. Nutrient
Requirements of Swine. Washington DC: National
Academy Press; 1998.
*38. Spencer BT, Tilley TJ. Low acid binding
feed for weaner piglets. Proc IPVS. Bangkok,
Thailand. 1994:279.
39. Holm A, Poulsen HD. Zinc oxide in treating
E coli diarrhea in pigs after weaning. Compend
Cont Educ Pract Vet. 1996;18:S26-S48.
* Non-refereed references.
|
|